SureStay Plus Hotel by Best Western Buffalo,  Buffalo

4.5/5  - based on 232 guest reviews.
65 US Highway 16 E, 82834-9393, Buffalo, United States - See map
+1 307 684 9564 +1 307 684 9568



Your room

> Room 1

1 adult


Hotel advantages

  • Air conditioning
    Air conditioning
  • Free parking
    Free parking
  • Outdoor parking
    Outdoor parking
  • 24-hour front desk
    24-hour front desk
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating
based on 233 traveler reviews
See more comments >>
Photo gallery :
The SureStay Plus Hotel Buffalo is conveniently located near the crossroads of Interstates 25 and 90. We are along US Highway 16 which is part of the Cloud Peak Scenic route of the Big Horn Mountains. Also our location is between Yellowstone National Park approximately 235 miles west of hotel and Mount Rushmore approximately 240 miles east of hotel. Our 100% non-smoking building has 2 floors with an elevator. Free breakfast provides eggs, breakfast meat, waffles, various pastries and breads, yogurt, cold cereals, juice, coffee, and tea. The indoor pool and hot tub are open from 8 a. m. to 10 p. m. and the fitness room is available from 6 a. m. to 10 p. m. The guest laundry is open 24 hours and has coin-operated machines. Limited number of rooms are pet-friendly with an additional daily fee of $10 per pet. Free parking is available with limited space for buses. Guests must be at least 18 years of age to register.

See rates and availability

Room 1

Guest reviews

in partnership withtrip advisor img
based on 233 guest reviews
Certificate of Excellence
Business Business 13
Couples Couples 94
Family Family 88
Friends getaway Friends getaway 11
Solo travel Solo travel 9
Sleep Quality
SureStay Plus Hotel by Best Western Buffalo,Buffalo
  • 4
    « Best Staff!! »

    The desk clerk was so kind and made us feel welcome, we were very tired after a long day. The staff was extremely pleasant and friendly. The room was exceptionally clean and comfortable. The breakfast selections were numerous and the staff person on duty that morning was so attentive she came out to ask us if we needed anything else. Thank you!

    « Nice, clean, quite accommodations »

    Stayed here just one night on our way through to Yellowstone. The service was friendly and helpful although we were bummed that the hot tub had been out of order and wasn't in service after a long day of traveling. Our room was clean and comfortable. Breakfast was good. A descent place for the $$

    « My family enjoyed our stay here. »

    I would stay here again. The front desk receptionist was very polite and friendly. She provided lots of information about the town of Buffalo, such as places to eat and things to see in the area.The room was clean, nicely decorated and the bathroom was spotless. The breakfast was tasty and hot. A great way to start the day.

    « Wonderful stay »

    We were greeted by a wonderful receptionist and a clean lobby. Very personable and accommodating. She also gave us a very fair price. She even took into account parking our long rig near our room. We had a door to the exterior as well as the interior of the hotel. Very convenient. Breakfast was perfect. Our room was clean and we had plenty of towels and supplies. Very happy with our stay.

    « Great spot & easy access »

    This property is a great choice with easy access to two major highways and city center. The pool and hot tub are clean and a perfect temp. The exercise facility is just right if you want to get sweaty. ?? Overall a perfect spot for our visit in Buffalo, Wy.

    « Great Stay! »

    We very much enjoyed this stay. We had a ground level floor that had a door going directly out and a door into the hotel. It was very clean even though it was a pet room! I could find any evidence of former animals, no smells, hair, or stains. The pool was great as well! Well maintained location and the breakfast was good. Recommend for anyone who is staying in Buffalo.

    « Exceptionally clean and convenient »

    Stayed in the Sure Stay during the last weekend in January. The place is immaculate. The clerk was very friendly. The rooms are basic and are as clean as a surgical suite. The beds were fresh and comfortable. The continental breakfast offered warm, fresh breakfast; far more than the buffet of carbs that are offered at most hotels. I highly recommend this hotel.

    « Passing through to yellowstone »

    This was an exceptional stay. Extremely clean. Huge breakfast spread. Pool was clean. I will come back. Staff was respectful. Cleanest hotel I have ever been to. Parked my car right outside my room door. Excellent accessibility. 100% satisfied. Would recommend to anyone traveling to Buffalo, Wyoming

    « Good affordable place in a town with many options »

    I was in a room nearest the highways and had only slight road noise. I had a good nights rest. The room was clean, comfortable, and roomy. It was nice to have both an interior door to the hallway and an exterior door to the parking lot. Only small issues in the bathroom where a towel rack not secured tight to the wall behind the toilet and paint on the ceiling around the heat light and fan. The breakfast was good with the standard items that one expects. Scrambled eggs, sausage patties, waffles with orange juice is what I had.

    « Good Value Stay enroute to Great Falls and Canada »

    We stayed here after a long drive from Moab, UT. Easy freeway access and this property is reasonably priced as a waypoint stop. Room was large, clean and comfortable. Front desk staff was helpful in directing us to a restaurant for dinner.

  • 5
    « Spent the weekend in Buffalo and stayed at the SureStay for the first time. »

    The room was very clean and comfortable. The finishes and the bedding were great. They have a very ice hot tub and pool. The room was very quiet even though it is right next to the interstate which makes it very easy to find and access. Parking was spacious and offered room for trucks with trailers. I would definitely stay there again.


    We found this hotel to be right off the highway with very easy access. The hotel is very clean and comfortable. All staffing that we met had smiles for us and said hello. The front desk staff were very helpful with restaurants close to the hotel. There are 2 steakhouses very close to the hotel and there is a gas station right across the street. We stayed for a night visiting family in town. The hotel was decorated for Christmas and very adorably done. They even painted their windows. We highly recommend this hotel

    « Very pleasant stay while passing through Buffalo »

    My wife and I spend one night here while passing though Buffalo on a recent road trip. The hotel was ideally located near the freeway, the staff were wonderful, the room was clean and very comfortable and the breakfast was all we needed to start our day. After a long days driving it was great to relax in a pool and hot tub.

    « Wonderful Hotel, Pleasant Stay »

    We stayed at the Sure Stay Plus for a weekend away to celebrate our anniversary. We were there a total of 3 nights. We arrived late evening the first night and I immediately noticed how good the building smelled when we walked into the beautiful, homey lobby. From the moment we checked in, until the moment we checked out, we had very pleasant service! The staff are very polite and helpful. Each morning we were greeted in the hall by ?hello's? and ?good mornings? by the housekeepers & other staff. I can't say that I've ever felt so welcome at a hotel before. On one morning at breakfast, another guest managed to spill and make a big mess of waffle batter, and he was less than polite about it. I was especially impressed at how the morning staff handled the situation. I personally would have been aggravated, but she was very nice about it all while she cleaned the mess very quickly, even though the guest wasn't very apologetic. That left a great impression on me. The breakfast is excellent! Fresh fruit, eggs, sausage/bacon, waffles, & plenty of variety. We got a filling breakfast each morning. The breakfast area was always spotless & there is plenty of room & seating. There's TV and a daily newspaper available while you eat. Fresh Hot coffee was always available. We are an active couple, so we're grateful for the nice equipment in the exercise room, along with a pool that isn't freezing cold. The pool and hot tub are very nice and very clean! We stayed in a single king room. It was very spacious and updated. The amenities were great for our extended stay: charging station, fridge, microwave, TV, and the perfect amount of furniture. The bed and pillows are very comfortable as well. The bathroom has beautiful granite & quality toiletries & linens. My favorite, by far though was the shower. The shower head was amazing! Perfect pressure and never ran out of hot water. I wish I could have taken it home! We are outdoor enthusiasts that enjoy the mountains and hiking, & enjoyed the history in downtown Buffalo. The hotel made our visit to this beautiful, friendly town a perfect get away. It has all our preferences in a hotel. We will definitely stay again and recommend you to everyone! Thank you!

    « Better than Motel 6 »

    There's a Motel 6 up the road in Sheridan that will save you about $30. But, you won't get the extras you get here. The room is considerably larger than the 6, but still not what I would call roomy. You get a good breakfast, scrambled eggs and bacon when I was there. There's also all the usual items for a good motel breakfast. I didn't notice the waffles (what a surprise :) ). I don't expect that you'll see the family of wild turkeys, in the parking lot, at the 6, but you might. This is, after all, Wyoming. The beds were good. The bathroom was small but OK. The AC pretty much worked, for October. They charge an extra $10 for your dog, which is why I didn't give a four. If you don't have a pet :(, you only have to pay an extra $20 over the 6. That makes it a really good deal.

    « Good place to stay while in Buffalo »

    Spent 2 nights at this hotel recently while visiting friends in Buffalo. Selected this hotel because of their connection with Best Western. The staff was very friendly and helpful. The ground floor room was exactly what we had requested as we have a service dog in training. The room's design allowed access to both the parking lot and the hallway to the front desk. The only reason I didn't rate this hotel a 5 star as the rooms and establishment does show signs of wear and is older, but we would definitely stay here again when visiting the area. The breakfast offered was complete with eggs and bacon/sausage and a good variety of other items.

    « Good place to stay »

    Our plan was to stay in Sheridan, but we couldn't get a room. The Best Western reservations suggested this hotel as a part of their group. I'm fairly picky about where I stay and was hesitant at first, but was pleasantly surprised. We were in the "newer part" and the room was large and very clean. I would definitely stay here again.


Getting to the hotel ...

All directions
·From: The Big Horn Mountain National Forest , stay on US Highway 16 eastbound. After entering city limits, highway name changes to Fort Street. When you reach the Main Street and Fort Street intersection, turn left onto Main Street. Go to the Hart Street and Main Street intersection and turn right onto Hart Street. Stay on Hart Street and go 0. 5 miles to the SureStay Plus Hotel Buffalo which is located on the right side of the highway. ·From: Interstate 25 northbound take Exit 299. Turn right onto US Highway 16. The SureStay Plus Hotel Buffalo is located on right side of highway. ·From: Interstate 90 eastbound take Exit 56B which connects to Interstate 25 southbound. Take Exit 299 and turn...

see more