SureStay Plus Hotel by Best Western Evansville,  Evansville

3.5/5  - based on 168 guest reviews.
19600 Elpers Road, 47725-8591, Evansville, United States - See map
+1 812 867 1100



Your room

> Room 1

1 adult


Hotel advantages

  • Air conditioning
    Air conditioning
  • Free parking
    Free parking
  • Outdoor parking
    Outdoor parking
  • 24-hour front desk
    24-hour front desk
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating
based on 168 traveler reviews
See more comments >>
Photo gallery :
This non-smoking SureStay Plus Hotel by Best Western Evansville is situated at the intersection of U. S. 41 and I-64. We are conveniently located near Cambridge Golf & Country Club, Vanderburgh County 4-H Fairgrounds, Toyota Manufacturing Corp. , Vincennes University Extension and Evansville Regional Airport. There are several restaurants within walking distance. The Eastland Mall is a 15-minute drive from this hotel and the Tropicana Casino is located about 15 miles from downtown Evansville. Our banquet/meeting room can accommodate up to 45 people. The SureStay Plus Hotel by Best Western Evansville was recently renovated and is 100% non-smoking and offers an indoor swimming pool, a meeting room that can accommodate up to 45 people, and offers a business center. All rooms include free Wi-Fi, flat screen TV, hair dryer, iron and ironing board, in-room coffee, microwave, and mini refrigerator. Our complimentary full hot breakfast buffet consists of scrambled eggs, one hot meat item, cream cheese & bagels, bread, muffins, yogurt, assorted juices, milk, assorted cereals, coffee, and tea.

See rates and availability

Room 1

Guest reviews

in partnership withtrip advisor img
based on 168 guest reviews
Business Business 43
Couples Couples 33
Family Family 53
Friends getaway Friends getaway 9
Solo travel Solo travel 23
Sleep Quality
SureStay Plus Hotel by Best Western Evansville,Evansville
  • 3
    « Room is fine, WiFi is crap »

    I have stayed here 3 times in just as many weeks. Every time, the WiFi drops off intermittently and I have to use my phone as a WiFi hotspot if I want to try to get work done. It is necessary for me to complete some work and I've never experienced such horrendous WiFi service anywhere else. I will be traveling to this location weekly for several months but I just don't think I can tolerate going back given the internet service being insufficient.

    « Pleasant stay »

    My family and I made an overnight stay at this particular SureStay Plus by Best Western during a family reunion in far southern Illinois. This location is directly south of Interstate 64 and about twenty minutes north of Evansville, Indiana. It appears that this property had recently been acquired by the Best Western brand from the Red Roof Inn chain as there were signs of remodeling that was ongoing and some of the in room literature about the hotel and amenities still listed the Red Roof Inn name. Overall it appeared very clean and inviting both inside and out. The landscaping was undergoing renovation as well so it appeared a bit shabby but the building exterior was well kept. We were assigned a room on the second floor and upon entering, the first bed appeared to be broken. A quick call was made to the front desk and we were given a new room with no hassle but it was a bit inconvenient as we were traveling with our daughter and her family and we had requested rooms next to each other. No big deal. I was also a bit disappointed as we had also requested a room with two queen size beds because my mother in law was staying with us and the beds were definitely not queen size and more like full size beds. My wife and I are full figured people and sleeping was a bit close but again, no big deal as we were only staying overnight. The room was clean and comfortable as well as the bathroom in the room. No complaints there. We made use of the indoor pool shortly after arrival and the pool area was clean and well stocked with towels but the pool water was a bit cold so we didn't stay in very long but we still enjoyed it after a long day. The hotel offers a morning breakfast consisting of the usual breakfast fare; eggs, sausage, biscuits, cereals, fruit, etc. Overall, it was palatable and convenient especially if you're on a budget and trying to save money by not dining out at every meal. I would both recommend and stay at this SureStay Plus by Best Western location again when traveling through the Evansville, Indiana area.

    « Nice Hotel even better price! »

    We just needed an overnight after some races. So really figured not a big deal if it wasn't so great. It was quit a bit cheaper than the others nearby, Was pleasantly surprised. The beds were very comfortable. The room was clean and looked like it had been freshly remodeled. Staff was friendly and helpful. Will stay there on the next trip to races.

    « Nice experience for a very budget class hotel. »

    This hotel far exceeded my expectations given the very low price. We were able to stay in one of the newly renovated, larger rooms and still came in way below what we thought we might pay. The bed was comfy, the room was clean and the breakfast was decent. The staff was super nice!

    « Awesome Renovation! Really great staff. »

    I am staying at the hotel right now and am writing the review from the hotel business computer. I really cannot believe how amazing this hotel has become. I stayed 3 years ago and the previous management was terrible, the hotel was outdated and the rooms even smelled... This hotels new manager Andy is the best I have seen in a while! He works every department and I don't even think this guy sleeps, he deserves a huge raise. The hotel is beautiful, breakfast has been upgraded and it's in a really quite area north of town. I definitely will be coming back.

    « Good stay but close to train track »

    The only reason that I lowered my score if this property to average is that there are trains going by, not too far away at all, all night long. If you're a light sleeper, this isn't gonna be good for you. Other than that, beautiful bedding, nice tv and channel selection and the standard breakfast.

    « Ugh,yuck »

    Went here because of decent reviews. For the price,they should be ashamed. After LONG trip in fog at night,arrived exhausted. First room actually was clean enough..cable didn't work. Called downstairs.person said they changed cable and have had problems but she couldn't fix it. Had a kid with me and needed some downtime. So we moved. Into a room from a B Movie or worse. Called person again to ask if she knew condition of room,she said no. Room had torn and stained lampshades,broken headbaords, broken phone with NO buttons!! A window with Some sort of white paint over entire window so you couldn't see out. Cable worked. I felt like I was in a bad movie. THIRD move...Room still had some clean lines issues and wear issues but better than #2. Cable worked. Was going to accept the bad experience but went to "breakfast" and was sick to my stomach. One pile of scrambled "eggs", a couple of grey sausage sticks. NO juice at all..machine spat out watery liquid instead.any breads or bagels that were out were hard as a rock. NO milk. NO One around, area. Cannot recommend AT all...again...the price wasn't EXACTLY all that cheap and worst experience I've had in a long time. No manager around the night issue or next morning before we left.

    « Overnight stay »

    We stayed here overnight while traveling. The first room was not clean but we were quickly given a different room. The room was comfortable for our overnight stay. My son left his glasses at the hotel and they were kind enough to send them to him at college which was very helpful as we were not going through Evansville again.

    « Hotel of choice for Trip to New Harmony and Evansville »

    Very pleased with this location, friendly staff, fast check in, basic but comfortable and clean room. Had a great hot breakfast next day. Eggs, sausage, waffle maker, the works! Very pleased, got my free bottled water since we are members! Will definitely stay here again for my next trip around this area!


Getting to the hotel ...

All directions
·From: St. Louis, MO Get on I-64 E. Follow I-64 E to US-41 S in Scott Township. Take exit 25A from I-64 E 2 h 15 min (156 mi). Continue on US-41 S. Turn right onto Rusher Creek Rd and the Hotel will be on your left. ·From: Louisville, KY Get on I-64 W. Follow I-64 W to US-41 S. Take exit 25A from I-64 W 1 h 30 min (103 mi). Continue on US-41 S. Turn right onto Rusher Creek Rd and the Hotel will be on your left. ·From: Nashville, TN Get on I-40 W/I-65 N. Follow I-24 W, I-169 and I-69 to US-41 N in Henderson 1 h 59 min (140 mi). Follow US-41 N (23 mi) Turn left onto Rusher Creek Rd and the Hotel will be on your left. ·From: Indianapolis, IN Take I-69 1 h 12 min (54. 7 mi). Follow I-69 to US-41...

see more